Saturday 27 April 2013

Heineken Cup Semi Final - Clermont v Munster


Inches separated Clermont from the Heineken Cup final last season but today’s chance for redemption against Munster is seen as theirs to lose, with Rob Penney’s men being given a 12 point handicap start upon their daunting trip to the French capital.

Some would say that defeat for a side that has only lost one home game from their last 60 matches – and that an unlucky one to a Leinster side that would then go onto beat Ulster by 30 points in the final – is inconceivable , but there are some areas of weakness for the visitors to attack.


Clermont were very impressive in their 36-14 win against Montpellier but were significantly outplayed in the first 20 minutes and only went in ahead thanks to a combination of the innovation of Morgan Parra along with the desperate injury to Francois Trinh Duc early on in the game. Clermont usually take time to find their stride into a game, but Montpellier’s early force at the breakdown, scrum, fierce counter rucking, and blistering line speed had Clermont rattled – and those are all classic Munster trademarks.


Rob Penney has tried to create a more expansive style of play this season which has had very mixed results from the sublime to the ridiculous but it was their traditional power and territory game that allowed them to turn over Harlequins and if the same tactics can be applied towards a Clermont side short of Gerard Vosloo – crucial to overturning at blindside then Penney’s men will feel like they have a chance.


However, this is a far tougher assignment than the one they had against a Harlequins side who were beginning to hit the physical wall of what has been a long, hard season, coming into the game on the back of three defeats after an LV Cup final success that had taken a lot of out of them. Unable to respond once Munster’s tremendous backrow had stopped them in their tracks and Ronan O’Gara was reversing every attack, Quins don’t boast the pack, or according to league results, all out quality of Clermont.


Preventing Clermont is also an 80-minute effort. Montpellier were unlucky to lose Trinh Duc so abruptly, but once Fofana touched down they were unleashed and quickly turned a one score game into a rout. Munster have the capabilities to slow them down and do damage if getting Conor Murray quick ball, but it has taken just one opportunity for the backline of Napolioni Nalaga (six tries in Europe from 6 games), Wesley Fofana (five tries in six) and Sitiveni Sivivatu (three in six) to break loose and no team is yet to respond to that.

In hindsight – as impressive as Munster’s efforts were – Quins, according to some, may have lacked a proper test in Europe this season before then, which is not something that you could level at Clermont, who were able to make more than 10 changes and still draw at Toulon in Marsellie – who needed an interception try to come back into the game – while then taking apart Toulose 39-17.

In the same time Munster came up against Leinster at Thomond Park and lost a hard fought game 22-16 against the same Leinster side that Clermont beat home and away in the group stages with the benefit of a stonewall TMO try disallowed, and while to write them off is folly, Clermont are rightfully heavy favourites for their first Heineken Cup final.

A handicap of 12 points is a little large for us considering that we are heavily on Clermont ante post – in any case, only 7 semi finals have been won by a bigger margin - and Munster are well capable of staying within that or the 6 point half time start they’re given, so if the weather stays good –there’s rain about  - then the advice would be to back a higher scoring second half, but this is one we’ll sit out, albeit with very nervous, bitten yellow fingernails.






No comments:

Post a Comment