Monday, 2 May 2011

2011 Punchestown Festival Day 1 - Growise Champion Novice Chase


6.40 Punchestown

Growise Champion Novice Chase (Grade 1) (Class 1)  (5YO plus)
Winner €49,600

Pick: Quel Esprit (win)

Head Of The Posse: Highlight of a memorable 6 timer for owner JP McManus when he was forced to work hard as he made it two from two over fences in the Grade 3 Ballybrit Novice Chase; Mistake ruined his chances in the Drinmore but shaped like a non-stayer in home straight and unable to make impact in Fort Leney Chase last time out.

Kakagh: Made up into useful sort over fences in past year, winning twice, but always behind when more than 60 lengths adrift of Mr Cracker in Grade 2 chase at Christmas (well below this level) and unlikely winner having been pulled up last time out.

Loosen My Load: Has had thoroughly consistent season, coming third in strong Grade 2 event at Cheltenham, then fourth in Grade 1 at Leopardstown; Has made bold bid the last twice, travelling well in Jewson Novice Chase and gaining a second through fall of Noble Prince in Powers Gold Cup latest; This race comes awfully soon afterwards.

Mr Thriller: Touted as serious prospect for Graded hurdles after running out a 15-length winner of the Silver Trophy Handicap Hurdle and then beating Champion Hurdle fifth at Haydock before ground and a mark of 160 stopped those ambitions; Was going to lay down a good challenge to Time For Rupert when falling 2 out on his chasing/seasonal debut but poor efforts since temper enthusiasm (hasn’t seemed stayer of the trip).

Quel Esprit: Impressed when landing Grade 3 over hurdles with ease but didn’t go on over hurdles after that; Impressive start over fences when beating useful Torphichen with ease on  one and only win to date, having fallen when looking set to take big hand in Grade 1 chasses the last twice,  in PJ Moriarty & RSA Chase at Cheltenham latest; Can play big part in finish if keeping on his feet.

Quito De La Roque: Has been transformed by fences, winning four from five this season, only defeat coming at the hands of RSA Chase winner Boston Charmer; Most impressive  performance by far when recovering from sloppy round of jumping (including catastrophic mistake 2 out) on ground presumed to be too fast for him; That makes him one to beat here.

Reve De Sivola: Has finally recovered form over fences, finishing an honourable third behind Bensalem and Carole’s Legacy in top handicap chase at Cheltenham Festival, and nearly coming out on top in a scrap at Aintree latest; That affair decent form for level but needs to brush up his jumping.

Thegreatjohnbrowne: Never really made most of potential over hurdles but has quickly made up for that over fences, winning beginners chase with ease and then following up with even easier win in Grade 3 at Punchestown; Made bold bid to lead all the way (behind Quito De La Roque & Western Chamrer) in Fort Leney Novice Chase but eventually well behind principals that day; Has to improve, been off 126 days, and no wins on anything faster than good to yielding.

Western Charmer: Holds strong claims on his second in one of strongest novice events all season at Christmas, and new career best when second in Irish National (giving lot of weight away to winner); That effort gives chance but drop back in trip wouldn’t help and is making a very quick reappearance.

VERDICT: Quito De La Roque shaped like an entirely different proposition last time out when showing immense tenacity and that makes him the horse to beat in no uncertain fashion, but QUEL ESPRIT has always shaped like he’d be able to take a big race if staying on his feet and he’s worth a chance to do so today.  Thegreatjohnbrowne has some improvement to find, while Loosen My Load might find this coming a little quickly. 

No comments:

Post a Comment